Links

  • Links
Photobucket
My Photo

Tip Jar

Support Blog

Tip Jar

Official Second Life Blog

EngageDigital

Readings

Creative Commons

  • Poll

« Why Geeks Should Not Be Allowed to Take Power | Main | Defne Demar AKA Burcu S. Bakioglu Discredits Her "Academic" Work All on Her Own »

June 03, 2010

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451cfe069e2013482e6f995970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Ты мне, я Тибет:

Comments

brinda Allen

ROFL!! ZOMG! While I was so tempted to translate the Cyrillic I'll just take your synopsis.

I wish I could have been a fly on her rl wall when you IMed her in Russian...I'm sure her perception of a (edited quotes:) swine, Jew, faggot, pedophile, old woman, hateful man, senior comrade
{Did I miss any?}
Didn't include a linguist.

Treasure Ballinger

I loved that too, that Prok IM'd her in Russian. Must've been quite a shock. Of course Prok could've saved himself the stress by just saying ok fine, stay in the group then, and pay the $4 per week. She would have exited and run screaming down the street soon enough.......sometimes you just have to allow people to learn the hard way when you try, and they just don't get it.

Prokofy

It's funny that you two aren't criticizing me for saying this, as being "rude":
Stop posturing and playing the victim. No one has asked you to pay money to visit a temple (!). But you don't have to join a group to visit the temple, either. The group is for paying tenants of *the houses and stores*. And that's ok, and it's perfectly fine, and we don't live in some socialist commerce-free utopia. This group is for people who *live here* or who wish to use the *events space*. If you don't in those categories, you don't need to join the group! Make your own group if you need a fabulous title to show off your wonderfulness. This group charges $5 a week to remain a member. So we expel people who don't figure out

See, that's the argumentation, that what I say here is "rude".

And my answer to that is, but what this person has done prior to my "rudeness" is the following:

o they've joined a group that no one asked them to join, and was not required to join merely to visit a place

o there are no group joiners there

o the land is open and so is the group

o the group charter, which you couldn't help but see when you pressed on ACTIVATE at some point, spells out very clearly in all caps DO NOT JOIN THIS GROUP UNLESS...

o even allowing for their bad English, this person assumed that if I expelled them from a group, and said it was for paying *tenants* only, that I was therefore a greedy swine who was collecting money to visit a temple. But...there is nothing remotely like that. There's a voluntary tip jar for the group that maintains the temple, a different group, and one for my SL Public Land Preserve. And that's ok. Tier needs to get paid.

o then having all this explained, the person starts in with the whole menu -- capitalism, Jews, pedophiles, faggots.

Treasure Ballinger

The reason it wasn't rude is because this conversation didn't even need to take place. Where do you find these people, Prok? She didn't need to join the group in the first place, and had she read the charter, that should have been clear. You said there were no group joiners which means she really had to go looking for this group. So, she found it, she misunderstood it and she joined it; you ejected her which was actually a favor, saved her a few lindens; and she started in on you. Because, she didn't get it. And with some people that will always be the bottom line, they just don't get it. And that's too bad. And kind of scary. Because it really wasn't all that hard.

Darien Caldwell

I never see being kicked out of a group as a 'favor'. that in itself is rude, especially without an IM explaining why. Personally I find leaving a group open to join but that 'isn't supposed to be joined' pretty much an act of griefing in itself. The whole situation is basically asking for this to happen.

Prokofy

I disagree. There isn't a group joiner, as I pointed out, and you'd have to consciously look for the group in search/groups to find it. If you did that much, you'd have to see the charter the first time you clicked on it, describing it, saying DO NOT JOIN THIS GROUP at the very top unless you are a tenant, and explaining also the $4 charge.

I think that's just geeky mechanicality and literalism to describe an open group as a "form of griefing" if it isn't meant "for everybody to be fabulous in". It's open *for the convenience of those using it for its purpose*. If someone wants to come in and use the buildings and rez a prim somewhere, they can. If someone wants to rent right away and start decorating, they can without queueing up waiting for an offline landlord to come online. Then I add ban powers to them and media powers.

If someone wants to organize and event and put it in the events list, they can do so without having to wait for someone to invite them by being online. Closed groups are a huge pain in the ass, and cost customers huge amounts of time and money -- they leave, even paying a cancellation fee, if they can't get their group invitation. I have waited 2 days for mall owners to show up and give me an invitation, the clock ticking on my paid money the whole time. I find that awful. I want merchants to come in, rent, and start selling immediately without being dependent. If somebody wants to leave a prayer flag or a flower, I want them to be able to do that.

But I will kick out people who join *just for the fabulous group and title to posture with* because they are merely exploiting it. If I see that in fact someone is an actual visitor using the place, i.e. a regular game player or temple helper or something, I don't expel them, and of course if they are a paying tenant.

But somebody whose groups include FREE EVERYTHING AND NOW THIS FREE THING TOO is expelled before they have a chance to send me an angry IM about being docked $4.

That's how I wish to organize it, and MOST PEOPLE get it. I get these kind of belligerent assholes only about 3-4 times a year, and I instantly blog about it as a deterrent : )

In this case, a person who doesn't read English might be understood. But I find that in most cases of people who don't read English (and therefore tend to tune out English instructions) say "Oh, sorry" and just move on their way. It's not as if there aren't a gadzillion other Tibet groups to join, and not as if they can't spend $100 and make one themselves with their friends!

I have to weigh the advantages here: dozens of tenants, merchants, and event planners getting the constant open use of this space, and seeing that it daily gets all kinds of visitors, and occasionally even gets events, not to mention paying tenants and their friends, who do stuff like put up landscaping and beautify the area versus a handful of entitlement-happy freaks who bang on me incessantly with screeching about me "exploting" the Tibet cause.

And, I know which thing I pick. I pick the ease of use of the larger group of people benefiting.

Treasure Ballinger

@Darien; I eject people regularly out of one of my groups. The group is an 'Artist's Rez Group' for artists that are actually exhibiting at this time, in our gallery. When their exhibit is over, and I am moving on to set up a new exhibit, there's no more need for them to have rez rights there, and it's time to add the new artists who will be exhibiting next. Someone always, always gets upset about being ejected from that group, even though to me, it's obvious why. The automated 'eject' message that a person gets when they're ejected is kind of harsh, could be a little gentler perhaps. So, yeah, I do send along an IM explaining (again) why they're being removed from the group, and thanking them for their participation. I hope that softens the blow a little, some remain upset, anyway....I really think it's the wording of the thing, but I don't think it's rude that I do it, it's the only way to manage the group.

Sean Williams

Gee, I really did get a laugh out of this whole thing ...

I'm not going to bother reading the entire IM log as there is no need to do so: It is opened with a harshly worded message from the group owner in response to someone whose grasp of English is piss poor at best.

Yep, fault all around ....

However there is never an excuse to send the sort of message you did after being sent two lines of text, with nothing inflammatory in it.

Way to go!

Maybe next time you'll do the smart thing and hit eject, respond to the questions without being a fuckwad, and then hit mute before things get out of hand.

Of course, you could always respond as you did in this case .... and then simply hit mute so you don't have to deal with it anymore.

Hmm, both of those are very novel and intelligent ideas! Wait .... that means you will not do either. Ah well!

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Search

  • Search
    Custom Search

Ads

  • Google AdSense

Ads

  • Google AdSense
Blog powered by TypePad

Google Analytics

Networked Blogs

  • Networked Blogs